Six Major Online Brokers Compared
“Ichinichi Shinyo” is Rakuten Securities’ product name. Comparable services at other brokers are also non-standardized margin transactions that must be closed on the day the position is opened.
| Broker | Service | Forced closeout fee for exceeding the deadline, including tax | Charging basis and conditions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rakuten Securities | Ichinichi Shinyo | Flat ¥2,200 | Standard trading plan; IFA plans have exceptions |
| SBI Securities | One-day margin | ¥2,200–¥7,040 | Telephone-order commission under the Internet plan; varies by executed value per order |
| Matsui Securities | One-day margin | ¥3,575 | Per order |
| Mitsubishi UFJ eSmart Securities | Day-trading margin | ¥2,200 | Per order |
| DMM.com Securities | Day-trading margin | ¥3,300 | Per execution |
| Monex Securities | One-day margin | Customer’s selected fee plan | Forced closeout at the deadline; distinct from the usual zero commission for one-day margin |
Rakuten Securities changed its forced closeout commission to a flat ¥2,200 for positions carried over on or after June 5, 2023. The same notice specifies ¥13,200 for IFA A and ¥2,200 for IFA B. Accounts opened through intermediaries therefore need to be checked separately from standard accounts.
SBI’s Fee Rises with Executed Trade Value
SBI applies call-center commissions to forced closeouts of its non-standardized margin positions, including one-day and HYPER short-selling positions. The Internet plan charges:
| Executed value per order | Commission, including tax |
|---|---|
| Up to ¥500,000 | ¥2,200 |
| Over ¥500,000 and up to ¥1 million | ¥3,960 |
| Over ¥1 million and up to ¥1.5 million | ¥4,840 |
| Over ¥1.5 million | ¥7,040 |
For example, a forced closeout with an executed value of ¥1 million costs ¥3,960; at ¥2 million, it costs ¥7,040. These charges apply even if ordinary online trades are commission-free.
Compare the Charging Units: Per Order or Per Execution
Even a fixed fee can multiply when positions remain open in several stocks. It does not mean ¥2,200 for the entire day.
Mitsubishi UFJ eSmart Securities groups forced closeout orders by stock, buy/sell category, market, account category, and margin category. It treats PTS trading as the same market as the TSE for this purpose. DMM.com Securities charges per execution, unlike brokers that charge per order.
Total costs depend on how many closeout orders are created and how partial executions are treated, as well as the stated fee.
Monex Distinguishes Deadline Expiry from Margin Calls
Monex’s official guidance applies the customer’s selected commission plan to forced closeouts for reasons other than a margin call, such as reaching the repayment deadline. This article therefore does not give a single fixed amount.
For forced closeout following a margin call, the call-center commission is 0.44% of executed value, with a minimum of ¥2,750 including tax. That minimum is not the fixed fee for exceeding the one-day margin deadline.
A one-day margin position not closed that day is forcibly closed at the opening of the next business day’s morning session.
Costs Beyond Commissions
The total cost of carrying a position overnight includes more than the forced closeout commission.
- SBI Securities: Interest on long positions and stock-borrowing fees after the deadline are 1.8% a year.
- Rakuten Securities: Special short-selling fees continue until settlement when a position is forcibly closed. Holidays between settlement dates also affect the number of chargeable days.
- Monex Securities: Interest, stock-borrowing fees, and special short-selling fees are calculated between the opening trade’s settlement date and the forced closeout’s settlement date, counting both endpoints and holidays.
Price-related gains and losses are separate. The next business day’s opening price can differ from the previous close, so a low commission does not imply a small overnight loss. Margin trading allows positions of roughly three times the margin deposit, and an adverse price move can trigger a margin call. Comparing fees alone does not establish the maximum loss. See Why Can Margin Trading Leave You in Debt? Margin Calls and Forced Closeout for the margin deposit and margin-call mechanics.
Avoiding Forced Closeout
Placing a closing order does not mean it has executed. Before the market closes, check execution status and remaining positions, whether cash settlement of a long position or delivery of shares against a short position is available, and the applicable deadline.
Matsui’s rules allow offsetting trades until the market close and cash settlement or share delivery until 15:45. Trading suspensions or special quotes may prevent a position from being closed. Check each broker’s deadlines and exceptions before trading.
Sources
- Rakuten Securities: Ichinichi Shinyo, Forced Closeout Commission Revision (published May 19, 2023).
- SBI Securities: Fees and Expenses for Forced Closeout of Margin Positions, Telephone-Order Commissions.
- Matsui Securities: One-Day Margin Trading.
- Mitsubishi UFJ eSmart Securities: Margin Trading Fees and Expenses, Margin Trading Rules.
- DMM: Domestic Margin Trading Commissions.
- Monex Securities: Forced Closeout Costs.
- Risk explanations refer to Japan Exchange Group: Overview of Margin Trading.
- Checked on October 1, 2026. For pages without publication dates, the check date is recorded. All commissions include tax. The comparison primarily covers standard individual accounts.